Coin Superstore
establishment
- Address
- 87 Franklin Ave, Nutley
- Phone
- (201) 242-2646
- Website
- www.coinsuperstore.com
- Hours
- Monday10 AM – 5 PM
- Tuesday10 AM – 5 PM
- Wednesday10 AM – 5 PM
- Thursday10 AM – 5 PM
- Friday10 AM – 5 PM
- SaturdayClosed
- SundayClosed
- Payment
- Credit cardsPer the shop's Google listing. Card payments on bullion often carry a surcharge, so ask before you pay.
- Rating
- 4.9 on GoogleGoogle's number, not ours, and it covers the shop rather than what they pay for coins.
About this shop
Buys and sells rare United States coins, classic commemoratives and gold and bullion, with certified material offered in PCGS and NGC holders. Stock runs to early copper such as half cents and large cents, 19th century silver, dollars, early type, modern issues and bulk common-date coins. The shop also takes in scrap jewelry, diamonds and watches, and handles appraisals, estate buying and liquidation. Business is conducted at retail and wholesale, through internet sales and at auction.
- Listed as a PCGS Authorized Dealer at its Nutley location.
- Its opening in Nutley was announced through the Nutley Chamber of Commerce.
- Trades as Coin Superstore LLC and also uses a Nutley post office box for mail.
Compiled by Coinsel from public information about the shop. What a shop deals in can change, so call ahead before a special trip.
Coin shows nearby
The next shows within 50 miles of this shop.
- New York International Numismatic ConventionJan 15–17, 202711 mi
- Garden State Coin, Stamp & Currency ShowDec 6, 202614 mi
- Westchester Stamp, Coin & Paper ShowNov 27–28, 202624 mi
Know your numbers first
Walk in with a value in mind. Look up the cert number on anything slabbed, and check recent sold comps so you can tell a fair offer from a fast one.