Is Your 1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin Worth Grading?
- With PCGS, a 1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin needs to grade AU58 or better for grading to beat selling it raw.
- With NGC, a 1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin needs to grade AU58 or better for grading to beat selling it raw.
That assumes one coin sent on its own with a new membership, a 13% selling fee, and a raw value of $1,050. Change any of it in the calculator.
Built by the Coinsel team. Fees verified against PCGS and NGC on November 14, 2026.
The chance the coin comes back as a Details grade.
Verdict
Grade it
- Expected gain
- $141
- ROI
- 81%
You break even if it grades AU58 or better.
Grading can still make sense if you want it authenticated or plan to keep it.
| Grade | Chance | Graded value | Net after costs | Vs. selling raw |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AU58 | $1,350 | $1,001 | $87 | |
| MS60 | ||||
| MS61estimate | 90% | $1,475 | $1,109 | $196 |
| MS62 | $1,550 | $1,175 | $261 | |
| MS63 | ||||
| Details | 10% | $840 | $557 | -$357 |
Cost breakdown
- Regular tier fee
- $42
- Handling
- $10
- Membership share
- $69
- Shipping to the grader
- $20
- Return shipping
- $33
- Total per coin
- $174
Values from the PCGS Price Guide and recent eBay sold listings. Updated November 15, 2026. See the 1915 $5 price page.
Sending several coins in one box? Price the whole submission.
1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin raw vs. graded values
A raw 1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin sells for about $1,050. The last two columns show what you gain or lose by grading it first, after grading costs and selling fees, compared with selling it raw.
| Grade | Graded value | Vs. raw, PCGS | Vs. raw, NGC |
|---|---|---|---|
| AU58 | $1,350 | +$87 | +$134 |
| MS61 | $1,475 | +$196 | +$243 |
| MS62 | $1,550 | +$261 | +$308 |
Values from the PCGS Price Guide and recent eBay sold listings. Updated November 15, 2026. See the 1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin price page.
1915 Indian Head $5 Gold Coin key facts
- Series
- Indian Head $5 1908-1929
- Year
- 1915
- Mint
- Philadelphia
- Mintage
- 588,000
- Composition
- 90% Gold, 10% Copper
- Weight
- 8.36 grams
- Diameter
- 21.6 mm
- Designer
- Bela Lyon Pratt
Checking a different coin? Use the full coin grading cost calculator, which also explains PCGS and NGC fees and how the numbers are worked out.
Estimates only. Not financial advice. Actual grades and sale prices vary.