Coinsel

1936 Buffalo Five Cents 1913-1938 MS65

Series
Buffalo Five Cents 1913-1938
Coin Type
1936-D 5C
Year
1936
Grade
MS65
Population
2287
Price guide value
$175.00
Cert #
73172158

Source: PCGS (fresh) · last synced 2026-11-20T21:20:07.426+00:00

Have one of these raw? Is this coin worth grading?

History

James Earle Fraser's five-cent design was approved in 1912, but release was held up for several months by objections from the Hobbs Manufacturing Company, maker of slug-detection mechanisms for nickel-operated machines. Fraser revised the dies, the company remained dissatisfied, and in February 1913 Treasury Secretary Franklin MacVeagh ordered the coins issued regardless. The first reverse placed the bison on a raised mound; once that mound was lowered, the resulting Type 2 reverse carried the series through 1938, with no nickels struck at all in 1922, 1932 and 1933. The 1936-D falls among the large late-series mintages that followed that interruption.

Details

Fraser designed both sides of the coin, which was struck in an alloy of 75 percent copper and 25 percent nickel, weighed 5.00 grams and measured 21.20 mm with a plain edge. The Denver Mint produced 24,814,000 pieces for the date. The D mint mark sits on the reverse, centered beneath FIVE CENTS, rather than on the obverse where newcomers to the series sometimes look for it.

Features

The obverse bears a right-facing Native American portrait, traditionally identified with Chief Iron Tail of the Lakota Sioux and Chief Two Moons of the Cheyenne, while the reverse carries an American bison with FIVE CENTS set in a recess below the ground line, the Type 2 configuration. Strikes on this date are usually fairly sharp, and the luster tends toward a subdued frosty texture, so a mushy strike is a warning sign rather than a normal trait for the issue. David Lange judged the 1936-D superior in strike to the 1934-D and 1935-D that preceded it. The important variety is the 3-1/2 Legs, catalogued as Cherrypickers' FS-901 and formerly FS-019, on which part of the bison's front leg on the viewer's left is missing, a lesser degree of loss than the fully absent leg of the 1937-D 3-Legs.

Notable facts

  • PCGS and NGC both certify the 3-1/2 Legs variety, though NGC's label text reads simply "3 Legs," which invites confusion with the 1937-D.
  • David Hall of PCGS ranks the 1936-D as one of the most common Buffalo nickels in all grades, scarcer in mint state than the 1936, 1937, 1937-D, 1937-S and 1938-D but not as scarce as the 1936-S.
  • Population figures compiled in March 2009 showed 71 examples graded MS67 between NGC and PCGS, with just two in MS68, both at PCGS.
  • An MS67+ example sold for $10,575 in December 2016, while the auction record for the date is $37,375, paid in January 2007 for an MS68.
  • The 3-1/2 Legs appears regularly in circulated grades from VG-8 through XF-40, and its premium over a common circulated 1936-D makes tooled and abraded fakes a predictable risk.

Sources

Coinsel uses essential cookies to run the Service, and optional analytics cookies to understand usage. See our Privacy Policy for details.